Skip to content
Kintsugi

Avalara vs Taxjar

Avalara prices every state separately, builds fewer than 80 of its 1,400+ listed integrations itself, and comes with long implementation and limited liability protection. TaxJar provides a simple setup for US sellers, but lacks global coverage and a ton of crucial features. Let's deep dive into Avalara vs. TaxJar to decide which platform best suits your needs.

Avalara and TaxJar product cards side by side

Avalara and TaxJar Compared

Avalara logo

Avalara is established in the market, but comes with complexity that modern businesses don't need - hidden fees, lengthy setup, and you still own the liability.

  • Setup Takes Months

    Avalara's price includes only Standard Implementation, a chat with an implementation agent. A scheduled implementation call, configuration review, and help resolving setup issues are sold separately as Guided Implementation.

  • Per-State Pricing That Adds Up

    Avalara's published plans start at $69 to $79 per state per month and only cover companies under $50M in revenue. In 10 states, Core Compliance runs $7,990 to $9,480 a year, plus $4,030 to register. Above $50M, or for VAT, it's a custom quote, so total cost is hard to predict.

  • Customer Service Issues

    Customers who switched to Kintsugi from Avalara tell us they dealt with poor support and fees they didn't expect. Avalara's included Standard Support is online cases with a 24-hour first response on weekdays and no phone; phone, live chat, and faster responses cost extra.

  • Locked Into Contracts

    Customer reviews describe predatory contract practices, with businesses feeling misled and trapped in agreements that are difficult to exit.

  • Reddit
    Vast-Association8113

    Horrible employees, horrible service, horrible value for the dollar. Predatory business practices. They lie, mislead, and use any tactic to trap you in the contract. avoid at all costs! There are many significantly less expensive and better options out there.

    2 Reply Award Share
  • Reddit
    LIAPHX

    Don't do it! Avatax is TERRIBLE. Implementation is bitch. Support is horrible. Managed returns are a joke - they've done our returns incorrectly despite asking them to correct (obvious) categories and now we have to amend multiple states and they are trying to charge us (this is an onboarding issue they need to fix.) They cant do NM and HI sourcing correctly. Had to set up custom rules which they agreed with. Without any knowledge of sales tax laws, you wouldn't know, but they are seriously fucking things up. DONT DO IT.

    2 Reply Award Share
  • Capterra

    'Don't use this software'

    Not good. Attempted to cancel, but had to jump through hoops and we are still being charged monthly. We had multiple changes in our dedicated support rep, and he would constantly cancel our scheduled meetings.

    Pros: Initially I thought Avalara was nice because it would calculate taxes on our behalf, then I realized the taxes calculated were wrong.

    Cons: Customer Support was horrendous and slow. Platform was difficult to navigate at times and it is overpriced.

TaxJar logo

Since Stripe acquired TaxJar, prices have gone up and integrations have been cut, and it still covers only the US. Customers who switched to Kintsugi from TaxJar tell us about slower, less helpful support since the acquisition.

  • US-Only Coverage

    TaxJar automates tax processes in the US but doesn't support Asia, South America, Africa, and Oceania - a dealbreaker for international growth.

  • Limited Integrations

    TaxJar no longer supports new NetSuite integrations, and its Stripe integration is for existing users only. Its Starter plan now starts at $39 a month, up from $19.

  • Setup Takes a Week

    TaxJar says getting up and running takes 7 days, typically. With Kintsugi's no-code integrations, most teams start monitoring nexus the same day.

  • Basic Automation Features

    No virtual mailbox for tax notices, no automated certificate renewal alerts, and limited AI-powered features compared to modern platforms.

  • Trustpilot

    Atomic Fireball

    US · 4 reviews

    Software is worthless with woocommerce

    Software is worthless with woocommerce. Plug-in doesnt work and will not collect tax.

  • Trustpilot

    David

    US · 2 reviews

    Very Bad Experience

    TaxJar significantly misled me during the subscription process followed by unbelievably bad customer service when trying to resolve the issues. Recognizing that I had been misled they agreed to a refund which was reversed over a year...

  • Trustpilot

    Run away fast

    US · 1 review, Jul 6 2024

    There is no way to contact them by...

    There is no way to contact them by phone when they overpay on you taxes. Email was send daily to resolve the issue. They offered no response after a few weeks I canceled my subscription. 6 months later still trying to resolve the problems they caused.

Avalara vs. TaxJar vs. Kintsugi

Why growing businesses choose Kintsugi

Kintsugi was built for how modern businesses actually operate. Get real-time visibility, predictable costs, and automation that works without constant developer maintenance.

  • Transparent Pricing

    No hidden fees or surprises. Clear pricing with no onboarding or implementation fees. Plan tiers based on filing volume or custom quotes for enterprise needs.

  • Complete Global Coverage

    Unlike TaxJar's US-only focus, Kintsugi handles multi-state US compliance plus international VAT and GST across all continents.

  • AI-Powered Automation

    Powered by Vertex, Kintsugi uses AI-driven technology for intelligent tax automation, real-time nexus monitoring, and automatic product classification.

  • Fast, Easy Setup

    No-code setup to sync your sales platform. Get started in hours, not months, with dedicated onboarding assistance and responsive support.

  • Seamless Integrations

    No-code setup with Shopify, Stripe, Chargebee, QuickBooks, and NetSuite. No integration nightmares or hidden consulting costs.

  • Responsive Customer Support

    Priority implementation and dedicated success management - not the "tickets that go nowhere" that Avalara customers report.

Switching to Kintsugi is easy

Migrating from Avalara or TaxJar is easier than you think. Our team handles the heavy lifting so you can focus on your business.

Avalara vs. TaxJar vs. Kintsugi

See how Kintsugi leads the way when comparing to players like Avalara and TaxJar

AvalaraTaxJarKintsugi
Easy OnboardingStandard Implementation (chat only) included; guided implementation sold separatelyTypically within 7 daysNo-code setup, get started quickly
Tax CalculationReal-time at point of saleReal-time through TaxJar APIAutomated real-time calculations
Platform Integrations1,400+ listed; fewer than 80 built by Avalara, the rest partner-builtShopify, WooCommerce, Amazon; no new NetSuite integrations; Stripe integration for existing users onlyShopify, Stripe, Chargebee, QuickBooks, NetSuite
Filing & ReportingAutomated filing and reporting dashboardsAutomated sales tax reporting and filing through AutoFileReports and filing-ready exports
Global CoverageUS and Canada in its self-serve package; VAT and GST across 190+ markets on custom plansUS only; doesn't support Asia, South America, Africa, OceaniaMulti-state and international jurisdictions (US, global VAT, GST)
High Transaction VolumeEnterprise-levelHigh-volume sellers on Shopify Plus, Amazon, ERP systemsReal-time computation for millions of transactions per hour
Advanced ReportingAvalara Insights analytics dashboardsReporting dashboard shows sales tax collected, owed, and filed by jurisdictionFinance dashboards with real-time tax liability monitoring
Support & SLAsStandard Support included (online cases, 24-hour weekday response, no phone); phone, chat, and faster SLAs are paid plansEmail replies within 1-2 business days; phone by emailed callback requestPriority implementation and dedicated success management
Security & ComplianceSOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001, role-based accessNo proof of SOC 2 or advanced security certificationsSOC 2 Type II, GDPR, role-based access
Error GuaranteeNone publishedCapped at 2x fees; late AutoFile onlyKintsugi Guarantee: we pay penalties or interest caused by our calculation or filing errors
Virtual MailboxNot availableNot availableYes (Kintsugi Mail)
Tax LiabilityYou own itYou own itKintsugi Guarantee covers penalties and interest from our errors (Premium)
Pricing TransparencyFrom $69–$79 per state per month (under $50M revenue), multiplied by every state; custom quote above $50M or for VATFrom $39/month (up from $19) or $99/month, rising with order volumeTransparent, no hidden fees
Implementation FeesNot included in the per-state price; Guided Implementation sold separately. Get it in writing in your quoteNo explicit implementation fees mentionedNo implementation fees
State Filing FeesIncluded in the per-state subscription, which multiplies by every state2 AutoFile credits a year on Starter (was 4), 4 on Professional (was 12); extra filings $50-$55 (was $30-$35)Included in plan tiers
Nexus MonitoringEconomic nexus tracking availableMulti-state tax compliance and automated jurisdiction filingReal-time nexus monitoring with alerts
Certificate ManagementExemption certificate management availableExempt non-taxable products via built-in sales tax categoriesAlerts when certificates need renewal

Get Started with Kintsugi

Automate your sales tax compliance with transparent pricing and AI-powered accuracy.

Frequently Asked Questions