Understanding Trump's Tax Proposals in 2025

Donald Trump's tax proposals —which include changes to the estate and gift tax exemption, adjustments to tax rates, and potential revisions to the estate tax—build on prior measures like the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) while rethinking broader tax provisions. From reevaluating how social security benefits and overtime pay factor into overall policy to modifying tax credits like the child tax credit, these ideas aim to simplify the code and spur growth.

Trump's suggestions also touch on tax policy tariffs and the corporate tax rate, potentially reshaping individual and corporate obligations. As conversations around Trump's tax proposals intensify, critics and supporters debate whether they will streamline tax compliance or deepen fiscal inequality.

What Is Trump's National Sales Tax Proposal?

Trump proposes replacing federal income taxes with a national sales tax, a concept that has stirred discussions among politicians, including Kamala Harris and President Biden. This landmark initiative is to streamline taxation, reforming how social security benefits are funded through new legislation.

By introducing a uniform tax rate at the point of sale, the plan seeks to abolish the complexities of the current tax system, making it more transparent. Consequently, it aims to reduce compliance costs both for businesses and taxpayers.

The proposal envisions a fairer tax system. It ensures that everyone contributes equally—no more loopholes for the wealthy. It also intends to boost consumption by allowing citizens to retain a larger share of their earnings under the new tax provisions.

Here's a list of Trump's proposed tax policy initiatives aimed at extending and modifying the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), along with introducing new measures:

1. Extending the 2017 TCJA Provisions: Trump plans to make the individual tax cuts from the TCJA permanent, preventing their scheduled expiration in 2025.
2. Restoring the State and Local Tax (SALT) Deduction: He proposes eliminating the current $10,000 cap on SALT deductions, allowing taxpayers to fully deduct state and local taxes on their federal returns.
3. Reducing the Corporate Tax Rate for Domestic Production: Trump suggests lowering the corporate tax rate from 21% to 15% for companies that manufacture products within the United States.
4. Exempting Certain Types of Income from Federal Income Tax: 4. Social Security Benefits: He aims to eliminate federal income taxes on Social Security benefits. 4. Tips and Overtime Pay: Trump proposes exempting income earned from tips and overtime pay from federal taxation.
5. Repealing Green Energy Tax Credits: He plans to fully repeal tax incentives for clean energy initiatives, including credits for electric vehicles, solar and wind energy, and home energy improvements.
6. Imposing New Tariffs: Trump has proposed implementing a universal baseline tariff of 10% to 20% on all imports, with higher rates for countries engaging in unfair trade practices. He also suggests specific tariffs, such as 100% on cars manufactured outside the U.S. and a minimum 60% tariff on Chinese goods.

These proposals reflect Trump's ongoing commitment to tax reform and economic policies focused on domestic production and trade balance adjustments.

Key Features of the Trump National Tax Proposal

Trump's plan centers on replacing federal income taxes with a national consumption-based levy, drastically simplifying how revenue is collected. By shifting the tax burden to sales rather than earnings, this approach promises more transparency and fewer compliance hurdles, raising questions about its long-term economic and social impacts.

Here are some of its key features:

• Single, Flat-Rate Sales Tax: This proposal replaces multiple income tax brackets with one standardized rate applied to all purchases at the point of sale. By adopting a uniform tax rate, the plan aims to simplify calculations for both individuals and businesses, eliminating a key source of complexity in today's system.
• Elimination of Federal Income Taxes: Under Trump's vision, Americans would no longer pay federal income tax, drastically reducing paperwork and compliance burdens. Supporters argue that ending income tax frees more disposable income for spending and investment, potentially stimulating the economy.
• Shift from Income to Consumption: Trump's national sales tax focuses on taxing purchases rather than earnings, fundamentally altering how the government collects revenue. Proponents say this structure encourages saving and investment, although skeptics worry it may disproportionately affect lower-income earners.
• Reduced Compliance Obstacles: By centralizing tax collection at the point of sale, the proposal aims to streamline business processes—particularly those strained by current tax regulations. In theory, fewer administrative hurdles mean more company resources to invest in growth, innovation, and job creation.
• Potential Impact on Existing Tax Breaks: The plan could reshape or replace certain credits and deductions, such as those linked to the child tax credit or estate and gift tax exemption. While this might close loopholes, it also raises questions about how families and high-net-worth individuals would navigate the new tax landscape.
• Focus on Transparency and Equity: Advocates of Trump's proposal highlight its promise of simplicity, with taxes visibly added at checkout rather than embedded in paychecks. The goal is an equitable system where everyone contributes uniformly, but opponents point to the inherently regressive nature of sales taxes as a key concern.

Why Trump Wants To Replace IRS With ERS

Trump has been campaigning to replace the federal income tax with high tariffs levied on foreign imports. There are even rumors that the president has plans to abolish the IRS (Internal Revenue Service) and establish an External Revenue Service (ERS).

The POTUS has been open about his intentions to reduce taxes for Americans. He spoke about this when he sat down for an interview with Fox News. 

"When we were a smart country, in the 1890s, you know, this is when the country was relatively the richest it ever was. It had all tariffs, it didn't have an income tax,"  Trump said. 

When asked whether he could abolish the tax, Trump gave an affirmative response. "There is a way...if what I'm planning comes out," he said.

Days later, Trump had an interview with Joe Rogan and he spoke about the same matter. He was adamant about replacing income taxes with tariffs.

Rogan asked Trump whether he was "considering getting rid of income taxes and replacing it with tariffs." Trump gave a similar response, telling the host, "Yeah, sure, why not?"

Trump confirmed his plan to establish ERS in a post on social media.

"I am today announcing that I will create the EXTERNAL REVENUE SERVICE to collect our Tariffs, Duties, and all Revenue that come from Foreign sources," he wrote on his Truth Social in January.

"We will begin charging those that make money off of us with Trade, and they will start paying, FINALLY, their fair share."

However, Democratic lawmakers were not supportive of Trump's plan. Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden, the top Democrat on the Senate Finance Committee, called it a "silly rebranding. "

"No amount of silly rebranding will hide the fact that Trump is planning a multi-trillion-dollar tax hike on American families and small businesses to pay for another round of tax handouts to the rich," Wyden said in a statement, per AP News.

What Experts Say About Trump's Tax Policies

Experts have mixed opinions about Trump's tax policies and plan to establish ERS. Some were supportive, while others criticized it.

Former adviser Steve Bannon supported the president-elect's plan when he addressed the matter in an event hosted by POLITICO. "Tariffs paid for everything up until the early 20th century," Bannon said. 

"But you wouldn't just look at tariffs, you look at everything about how you can charge fees essentially, whether that's on investment, whether that's on other things of access to this country. America's behind the golden door, OK? And this market is the most robust, lucrative market in the world, and we shouldn't just let people have access, we shouldn't let foreigners have access to this market and to the American people and American citizens for free," he added.

Gerald Celente, business consultant and publisher of The Trends Journal, also approves of Trump's move.

"Trump says he will abolish U.S. income tax and "Instead of taxing our citizens to enrich foreign nations, we should be tariffing & taxing foreign nations to enrich our citizens," Celeste wrote on X, formerly Twitter. "I totally agree. Bravo!"

Meanwhile, Kimberly Clausing, economist and Professor of Tax Law and Policy at the UCLA School of Law, called Trump's plan to establish a new agency to handle tariffs a "deeply impractical plan."

"First, we already have a Customs and Border Protection office...including officials who collect tariffs. Second, it seems like an odd move for an Administration supposedly focused on efficiency to suggest a redundant government agency as a solution," she said.

Daniel Shaviro, Professor of Taxation at the New York University School of Law, also weighed in on the plan to collect higher tariffs. For him, it requires "more of an enforcement network," but the people need not file annual income tax returns. However, when asked whether tariffs would suffice to replace income tax, he said "no."

Why Trump's National Sales Tax Matters Now

From Donald Trump's earlier tax proposals—including changes to the tax rate, revisions to the estate and gift tax exemption, and debates about the corporate tax rate—it's clear that overhauling how Americans are taxed isn't new.

Yet this plan to replace federal income taxes with a national sales tax has sparked discussions among figures like Kamala Harris and President Biden, raising further questions about tax credits, social security benefits, overtime pay, and how the estate tax might be adjusted under new tax provisions.

Positioned in the shadow of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) and debates about tax policy tariffs, the proposal shifts taxation from income to consumption, with potential ripple effects on everyday spending and the child tax credit. By advocating a uniform tax rate, Trump aims to reduce bureaucracy, possibly streamline compliance, and reshape fiscal policy for both individuals and businesses.

Future of Trump's Tax Proposal

As debates intensify around this national sales tax plan championed by Trump and discussed by Biden, successful reform hinges on clear strategies and cross-sector collaboration. Policymakers must offer a phased roadmap that balances the plan's promise of simplicity with potential equity challenges, sustaining consumer and business confidence.

Widespread partnerships among government bodies, financial experts, and the public could refine the proposal to accommodate other Trump tax proposals, updates to the TCJA, potential tax policy tariffs, or child tax credit adjustments. By embracing forward-looking policies, America could transform looming fiscal hurdles into avenues for sustainable growth.

Kintsugi is the ultimate sales tax automation tool to simplify tax compliance for e-commerce and SaaS businesses. Whether you're dealing with complex tax rules across multiple jurisdictions or just want a hassle-free solution, Kintsugi ensures accuracy, compliance, and efficiency. Take control of your sales tax today—sign up for Kintsugi or book a demo to see it in action!